Hi,
Well I suppose you live and learn. This is the first barley wine I've drunk so I probably was misguided as to what to expect.
As regards your comments on aging, the O'Hara's barley wine was recommended by a couple of people and as I needed a dessert beer for last Saturday night, it wasn't likely to get aged too long ... unless O'Hara's had aged the bottles already?
Having said all that, if barley wines are generally subtle in flavour then perhaps they aren't for me. I normally like beers and wines with strong aromas and flavours. I prefer not to have to search for hints of things that may or may not be there!
When I'm reaching for an 8% plus beer next time I'll hopefully find something with complexity and character ...
Tim